My third grader’s social studies book, “Communities,” is rather interesting.
The boys have been sick, so the textbook got sent home for some make-up work.
Whee.
My son’s assignment was in Chapter 3, People Move From Place To Place. (Ha. He’s kinda familiar with that concept, being a military brat and all . . . )
The first page highlighted one of the book’s many “Citizen Heroes.”
Jane Addams.
Yep.
Jane Addams.
I knew I had heard that name before, and the Hull House she started. The dates were a dead giveaway: the Progressive Era.
A consultation with Jonah Goldberg’s Liberal Fascism confirmed it. There she was, in all her progressive socialist communist collectivist glory:
“[W]e must demand that the individual shall be willing to lose the sense of personal achievement, and shall be content to realize his activity only in connection to the activity of the many.” (page 87)
Of course, the third grade Social Studies textbook does not delve into the specifics of political ideology. It merely highlights Addams’s upbringing (her father taught her to treat everyone fairly), her good work (opening a special place for immigrants), and her accomplishments (being the first American female to win the Nobel Peace Prize because she worked hard to help world peace).
In the corner of one page is a helpful List Of Citizenship Traits: Caring, Respect, Responsibility, Fairness, Honesty, and Courage.
While Addams is specifically listed as an example of fairness, I have to assume she was both honest and courageous when she declared the Bolshevik endeavor:
“the greatest social experiment in history.” (page 102)
Fantastic.
Further into the lesson came the paragraph titled, “A Nation of Immigrants.”
Super-mega-fantastic.
Michelle Malkin says it best:
“[A]s I’ve noted many times over the years when debating both Democrats and Republicans who fall back on empty phrases to justify putting the amnesty cart before the enforcement horse, we are not a ‘nation of immigrants.’ This is both a factual error and a warm-and-fuzzy non sequitur. Eighty-five percent of the residents currently in the United States were born here.
Yes, we are almost all descendants of immigrants. But we are not a ‘nation of immigrants.’”
Finally, the lesson (mercifully) concluded with some examples of Nice Immigrants Who Did Things, like Mary Antin and the guy who painted the famous Washington Crossing the Delaware.
Let me just say.
Explaining to a mostly disinterested eight-year-old why I have a problem with the Nice Lady Who Opened A Nice Place For Immigrants is . . . challenging.
I did it anyway. In the car on the way to the vet to pick up Sussie (again). My son read his assigned pages aloud, and I stopped him whenever I had an issue.
Which was frequent.
I can’t remember everything I said, but I remember getting riled up. Spittle may have hit the windshield.
The boy thought my spirited reaction was funny, and that is absolutely okay. We had a great talk. We discussed which is more important, the group or the individual. I explained that it’s not his teacher’s fault, because she doesn’t know there is a progressive/liberal bias in her textbooks.
She probably thinks it’s filled with standard, basic, what-a-3rd-grader-needs-to-know facts.
We even talked about why so many people don’t realize this textbook is providing the building blocks for Standard Leftist Lies. This was my favorite part of the conversation, because my son finished a sentence for me in a completely accurate way.
You see, he’s been learning multiplication tables, which of course involves drills. So I pointed out the fact that, if I had wanted to, I could have told him that 4 times 7 equals 29, over and over and over.
I continued, “You would have believed that 4 times 7 equals 29, because . . . “
I wasn’t sure what came next. As a parent, the only thing that came to mind is: because I said so.
But he knew why he would become convinced that 4 times 7 equals 29:
“Because you get used to it.”
Drills. Repetition.
Repeat the lie often enough, and it becomes truth.
We talked about the “fairness” thing too, and that was easy. All kids like to protest that “it’s not fair!” Mine never get away with it without hearing me say: “Life’s not fair. Get used to it.”
There is no such thing as fair.
There is liberty, justice, and there is the rule of law.
There is no fair.
I explained to my third grader about how the left’s need for “fairness” might be the reason for the “nation of immigrants” lie.
After all, our Founding Fathers were immigrants who got a chance for a new life in America. If our Founders got such a chance, it’s only fair we give all of today’s immigrants the same chance for a new life, too, right?
So we can’t say no to anyone who wants a new life in America, because that wouldn’t be fair. If everyone on the planet wanted to come, we’d have to let them.
“Then we’d have to leave and start a new America,” my son remarked.
Exactly, my brilliant child.
By the way, I’m just bragging now.
It’s late. I’ve got research on the authors of this lovely textbook. They will have to be the subject of my next post. Yep, you guessed it. The authors’ backgrounds are . . . interesting.
Recent Comments